Hemnet vs Booli - The debate creates press

It comes as no surprise that the Swedish start up Booli (a start up offering search engine for residential listings on the Swedish real estate market, earlier coverage) was going to create a debate in the market.

However, earlier this week Lars Kilander, CEO of Mäklarsamfundet (the Association of Swedish Real Estate Agents), made it easy for many papers this week to create selling headlines with the quote (my translation)  "We don't believe it is better with more listing services, it just gets more complicated for the buyers". 

I guess that there are few things that customers dislike more than being told what they like.

Press about the debate (in Swedish)
DN:  the article by DN (the largest newspaper in Sweden)
Metro: here 
DinaPengar: here
Realtid: two articles here and here
DagensPS: one
JönköpingsNytt: an article  (with a slightly different approach)
From the blogosphere: here, here, here

The response from Booli
Is found here.

The letter
The background is that the press has found out that a letter has been sent to all members of Mäklarsamfundet asking their members "to protest" against Booli in order to keep their 'own' service Hemnet  (read more) as 'the one and only' listing service (forgetting that there already exist another one in Bovision).

 

MySQL consultants more expensive?

The most interesting presentation at the the IT fair was given by Magnus Stenberg from MySQL (an open source database provider from Sweden bought by Sun Microsystems for 1 billion USD).

The topic was if property management systems are ready for an open source approach. The question wasn't really answered. It was more about the story of MySQL and how clients in general could use their database technology. A very interesting presentation though.

Started a debate
Anyway, since I believed that there was to little debate and I wanted to increase the temperature I stated that one of the reasons when suppliers don't go for mySQL could be that they believe it will be more expansive when it comes to hire consultants in this field and referred to an article in Computer Sweden (the largest IT paper in Sweden). Not surprisingly, this point was denied. (Even   laughed at which in a sense proves the point...)

The 'fact'
Unfortunately I wasn't able to defend my point (I wasn't given the microphone) with 'facts' (it is still just an article) and showing the actual source of my point, so here is the link to the article (in Swedish). The story is about that an 'open source' consultant could cost up to 1 500 SEK/hour, compared to 950 SEK/hour for a .NET developer.

Of course, there is not one (1) truth when it comes to prices and it will change over time. My point is still that it could be one of the reasons why a company hesitates to make the change to open source program. Not saying that it's wrong to go there.

Well, at least the temperature raised....   ;-)

IT & Property Fair in Sweden

Today I attended the IT & Property fair in Sweden called 'Fastighetsbranschens IT-dag' (Swedish) which is arranged by SeminarDesign. This is the second year.

IT_dagen-2008_450px.jpg

I hoped that it should have grown since last year, but the number of attendees (130) and exhibitors (6) is almost exact as last year.  Hopefully it will grow in the future because I believe there is need for an event as this one. If not for our suppliers and believers to meet up an discuss 'war stories'.

ARGUS Software starts blogging

The vast majority of the RE.net (and here) blogs are towards the residential public. Therefore, I'm delighted to find out that ARGUS, one of the largest suppliers of financial software to the commercial real estate industry, has started a blog dubbed 'Global Viewpoints'.

Argus_Blog_450px.jpg

ARGUS describes the blog as;

"This blog is produced by ARGUS Software. The blog will cover a range of topics related to the global landscape for real estate investment and development, and blog visitors will have an opportunity to share their opinions on blog topics. The blog also will serve as an educational tool and provides information including industry reports and recently published books related to real estate, as well as a list of global industry events and links to industry media outlets."

They started of in the early November and has so far been able to produce a large number of posts. It will indeed be interesting reading. Especially with this list of writers.

 

Property information standards show results

Fi2.jpgToday I attended an open meeting with the Swedish standardisation organisation Fi2 (in Swedish 'Föreningen för förvaltningsinformation') which aims to make it easier to exchange information within the lifecycle of a (commercial) property.

The organization was founded in the mid 90s and is showing more and more results. Especially among suppliers of Property Management Systems but also in the new field of energy reports that from 2009 must be reported to The National Board of Housing, Building and Planning from 2009.

Pisces in the UK
Another organization that shows result in the area of standardization is PISCES.jpg the UK based organization PISCES. At the PCS Expo in London in October an impressive presentation was conducted by Chris Lees from Calvis had a brilliant walk through of the project how one of UK's largest property owners has gotten four law firms to use Acrobat Reader documents to fill in and send the lease agreements (including over 200 data fields) using a PISCES standard XML schema. Read more about this at this Realcomm Advisory.

The need is there but it is hard work
There is no question that there will be benefits for standards in the real estate industry but it is hard work to set it in place. So I'm very impressed by those people and companies that is putting efforts behind it. Keep up the good work.

 

Going bedouin - The Thailand experience

As a believer in the power of the web I don't see the limitation that work could one be done in an office. With this in mind, and the fact that the winters in Sweden aren't what they have been, I have gone bedouin for a couple weeks.

A Swede that doesn't like the winter?
First of all, I need to explain this (since so many ask me this). I love a real winter with snow, minus a few degrees and clear blue sky. However, the winters in Sweden (at least not in Stockholm) are not like that right now. More a few degrees above zero (the proof), rainy, dark and gray clouds.

Sthlm_vs_Lanta_450px.jpg

Left:  Stockholm a winter day (source: http://www.konradolsson.se/)
Rigt:  Bamboo Island, Thailand

Why go bedouin?
To quote Greg Olsen "because you can". Greg coined the phrase 'Going bedouin' in late 2006, read more about how the phrase spread from there. By the way, Gregs employer Coghead is indeed structured the bedouin style.

How does it work?
First of all, you need the forward thinking of the management with respect to "just get the work done".  Secondly, an IT infrastructure based on web applications or being able to access them using for example Citrix. Then bring your laptop. Find a hotel with WiFi. Go.

The benefits
For me; I'm able to extend our stay in Thailand with three weeks. I'm also able to get rid of the normal distraction of office life and sit down and write those use cases for new functionality.
For the employer; do my job as I as was sitting at my chair (keep in mind that I conduct the vast majority using mail and IM)

More about 'going bedouin' 
'Extreme telecommunication'    An CNN article
'Freedom from the officeFrom ComputerWorld
'The future of the workplace'   ABCNews
'Small is essential' an article in Time about the company 37signals
'Location independent A blog/site about 'going bedouin'

 

Booli.se - A Swedish Trulia launches today

Less than three weeks after Hemnet told us that there is no need to improve a new competitor today enters the Swedish residential listing market... 

Booli_Start_400px.jpg

The service is called Booli (in Beta mode of course) and is aiming to be the search engine for residential listings and market information in Sweden.

The people behind Booli
Two weeks ago I had the opportunity to sit down with two of the founders, Anders Kyhlstedt (Head of Marketing) and Peo Nilsson (CEO). Both are serial entrepreneurs that see an inefficient market. They are teaming up with Daniel Kapland, a very successful Internet entrepreneur, who runs the incubator Firm Factory. In total there are some 10 people working at Hemson Sök AB (the company behind the service).

My first impression
After playing around an hour with the tool, I'm indeed impressed. There is no question that this crowd has extensively Internet experience and a vision how to create a consumer product.

Booli_Karta_400px.jpg

 

Functionality I like...
... saving listings, so easy but so powerful
... my placard, which display what has happened in my area of interest (including listings that has been removed)
... easy to update the search list
... great mapping functionality
And from the discussion with the founders I know that there is more to come. Even maybe some Zillow functionality... (it is also stated on their site)

How they do it
Booli is first of all a search engine finding listings at the brokers sites. They don't primarily use crawlers (collect the data) sites like Hemnet or Bovision. According to a Booli (unconfirmed) comment in this blog post, less then 1% of the listings are from other listings services.

Business model
Based on advertisement and, I assume, enhanced listings in the future. There is no question, that they have been inspired by services like Trulia and Nestoria. Their goal is first of all to be a tool for the consumers (not the broker).

Challenges?
However, the do have quite a few challenges;
... trust, the consumer must trust that Booli has at least the same number of listings that Hemnet (or  Bovision for that reason). The functionality has limited value if the listings aren't there
... the reaction from the brokers community, there has been people trying this before but hasn't been successfully
... stamina to let the people get used to run their residential search here instead
... take it from Beta mode (it is still only for greater Stockholm and according to themselves, there are more listings in the database than on the site)

It will be very interesting to follow the evolution of residential listing.
Let the fight for the customers begin.

 

Additional reading is found hereherehere and here (all in Swedish).

Hemnet crashes, releases a new platform and is named "the most underdevloped site in Sweden" in one week

It has for sure been a busy week for Hemnet, the number one listing service in Sweden for residential homes.

Server crash put a hold on updates
According to an article in Dagens Industri (financial paper) a server went down last Saturday and put a hold to all updates put in by brokers on that day. The irony is that this was just a few days before their switch to the new platform (se below).

Upgrading the technical platform
Earlier this week (but after the crash) Hemnet introduced their new platform (press release in Swedish). The old one had been around for 10 years.  From a user perspective the only difference is a new mapping functionality. This is the second switch of mapping in a year.

In the DI article above explains Hemnet CEO Björn Dietmann that the main reasons for the upgrade are:
   1. to secure the availability
   2. to make the publishing process of new listing easier and faster

In other words, less focus on the end user. Which comes to no surprise since Hemnet is owned by the brokerage community (and two large newspapers). Hemnets explanation (in the DI article) is that their user groups have strongly demanded NOT to change how the site works. Isn't there a way to add better functionality and still keep the basics searches as they are?

"The most underdeveloped site in Sweden"
As a comment to the new release, with lack of major improvements for the end user, the Swedish blog webstrategi.se describes Hemnet to be 'the most underdeveloped site in Sweden". 

Robert (the author behind the blog) for sure has a point if you ask me. Hemnet is a great service since it consists of 90%(?) of all listings. However, if you search actively for a new home (like me and my wife where 6 months ago) there are easily 20 new functions that one would have appreciated greatly.

My suggestion to the owners of Hemnet, make the 'feed' of listings available to other to build web sites on. That would increase the marketing of your listings. Isn't that the point?